Showing posts with label EV: Foreign Influence. Show all posts
Showing posts with label EV: Foreign Influence. Show all posts

Friday, 19 September 2008

Chesnut Born Again

RA Chesnut, Born Again in Brazil: The Pentecostal Boom and the Pathogens of Poverty, (London: Rutgers University Press, 1997)
A Prophetic History

“With little access to the city's precarious health care facilities and neglected by the Catholic church, many ill Belenenses and their families came to the Assemblies of God as a last resort.”1 (28)
refers to trips made by Berg and Vingren to the Southeast and the change of HQ to RJ in 1930.2 (29)
Swedish leaders decision to nationalise the church in 1930.3 (30)
Although CC growth was faster in the earlier years it was also highly regionalised, whereas by 1940 AoG had spread to all states and territories.4 (31)
Persecution of Protestants in Vargas era; Neo-Christendom, stoning of churches but few lost their lives.5 (33)
National Evangelisation Crusade--> novelty; wide press coverage, collective healing sessions.6 (35) Followed by resistance from Pentecostal leaders so that Williams founded Crusade Church which then became IEQ.7 (36)
Use of sertanejo rhythms helped Manoel de Mello's success amongst Northeastern migrants.8 (37)
Exorcism a major feature of Deus e Amor church including calling upon evil spirits from Umbanda to be collectively exorcised by congregation.9 (38-39)
“Unlike the omnipresent Jesus and Holy Spirit of Pentecostal churches, the saints of popular Catholicism tend to be fixed to particular locales and do not travel easily.”10 (40)
claims that many Pentecostal leaders because women can use it to challenge the authority of the pastors.11 (43)
“Middle class Pentecostals in the Central Temple and larger churches had little tolerance for the rustic Portuguese of unlettered preachers.”12 (43)
prefers the term postmodern to neo-pentecostal as the latter does not allow one to distinguish between the modern BPC and IEQ and the IURD.13 (45)
claims that prosperity theology was imported from the US.14 (47) refers to a “five keys of prosperity change in an IEQ church.15 (178 note 18)

Monday, 2 June 2008

Martin

Pentecostal anticatholicism: dislike of papism, Marianism and syncretism; experience of persecution1 (236)

unlike historical denominations, Pentecostals are unwilling to work with Catholics2 (236-237)

"Christian Lalive D'Epinay sees Pentecostalism as a refuge for the masses which reproduces much of the closeness and the patronal relations of the hacienda...allows a man to be alienated from society...offers him a free space wherein he may retain at least some dignity."3 (243)

"Brazil was a second "frontier" for many US missionaries because some Southern colonists sought refuge in Brazil after the Civil War."4 (255-256)--> encouraged quietism in politics (256)

"any social change connected with Protestantism is restricted to the level of culture rather than structure."5 (256)

Presbyterian church--> struggle for national independence; conflict between youth and central bureacracies; after 1964 latter preferred authoritarian solutions6 (256-257)

"Pentecostalism went native precisely in the way that many missiological theorists prescribe but in doing so it reproduced some of the features of Brazilian society that one would expect Protestantism to challenge" such as issues of patronage and honour and shame7 (257)

defines favelas as rural subcultures looking at an alien urban world."8 (258)

Pentecostalism: mutual support; emotional release; sense of ID+dignity; substitute society caring for its own9 (258)

Points to Brasil para Cristo's resistance to the military regime10 (258-259)

discussion of issue of patronage+authority: Pastors instructing members how to vote11 (259)

Politically Baptists--> Moral Majority; Pentecostalism--> central; Historical Protestants--> strongly left or right12 (259)

"The Latin American heirs of the Iberian empire have suffered cumulative political and economic defeat at the hands of the North American heirs of the British Empire"13 (271) sees this as the context in which the arrival of Protestantism in Latin America is to be interpreted14 (272)

Voluntarism; revivalism and participatory enthusiasm of Evangelical Protestantism in England intensified in North American15 (273-275)

in America "the prototypes of Pentecostal and evangelical religion now went into full cultural reproduction ready for eventual transportation across the Rio Grande"16 (274)

In Latin America after 300 years in which religion and social fabric were held together as one process of differentiation is occurring17 (278) similar process occurred in Britain and then in America. These countries influenced Latin America but nonetheless process is independent.18 (278)

" As the sacred canopy in Latin America is rent and the all-encompassing system cracks, evangelical Christianity pours in and by its own autonomous native power creates free social space"19 (280)

Religious influence part of a wider American influence in Latin America20 (280-281)

points to American influence on Catholicism: 1) Charismatic catholicism begun in North America 2) priesthood comes from N. America 3) many partisans of Lib Theology educated/come from North America21 (281)

Latin American Pentecostalism as the Latin Americanization of American religion22 (282-283)

influence of urbanization: "Evangelical Christianity is a dramatic migration of the spirit matching and accompanying a dramatic migration of bodies."23 (284) loss of all ties that bind, familial, communal or ecclesial24 (284) "new cell taking over from scarred and broken tissue"25 (284)

Catholicism--> ecclesiastical functionaries tended to be more concerned with their careers than Catholic devotion, concern with entering political and social elites.26 (288)

Pentecostalism--> first encounter for many with biblical based, personal faith27 (289)Catholic responses in Catholic action and Liberation Theology28 (289)

"Liberation theology has a decided middle class and radical intellectual alien to the localized needs of the 'poor'"29 (296)

re: Secularization tends tentatively to European exceptionalism as in Latin America unlike Europe Protestantism/Pentecostalism came with the rupture of the sacred canopy, not being part of the sacred canopy itself 30(296-298)

1D. Martin, Tongues of Fire: Explosion of Protestantism in Latin America,(Oxford: Blackwell Publishers, 1990) 236.

2D. Martin, Tongues of Fire: Explosion of Protestantism in Latin America,(Oxford: Blackwell Publishers, 1990) 236237.

3D. Martin, Tongues of Fire: Explosion of Protestantism in Latin America,(Oxford: Blackwell Publishers, 1990) 243.

4D. Martin, Tongues of Fire: Explosion of Protestantism in Latin America,(Oxford: Blackwell Publishers, 1990) 255256.

5D. Martin, Tongues of Fire: Explosion of Protestantism in Latin America,(Oxford: Blackwell Publishers, 1990) 256.

6D. Martin, Tongues of Fire: Explosion of Protestantism in Latin America,(Oxford: Blackwell Publishers, 1990) 256257.

7D. Martin, Tongues of Fire: Explosion of Protestantism in Latin America,(Oxford: Blackwell Publishers, 1990) 257.

8D. Martin, Tongues of Fire: Explosion of Protestantism in Latin America,(Oxford: Blackwell Publishers, 1990) 258.

9D. Martin, Tongues of Fire: Explosion of Protestantism in Latin America,(Oxford: Blackwell Publishers, 1990) 258.

10D. Martin, Tongues of Fire: Explosion of Protestantism in Latin America,(Oxford: Blackwell Publishers, 1990) 258259.

11D. Martin, Tongues of Fire: Explosion of Protestantism in Latin America,(Oxford: Blackwell Publishers, 1990) 259.

12D. Martin, Tongues of Fire: Explosion of Protestantism in Latin America,(Oxford: Blackwell Publishers, 1990) 259.

13D. Martin, Tongues of Fire: Explosion of Protestantism in Latin America,(Oxford: Blackwell Publishers, 1990) 271.

14D. Martin, Tongues of Fire: Explosion of Protestantism in Latin America,(Oxford: Blackwell Publishers, 1990) 272.

15D. Martin, Tongues of Fire: Explosion of Protestantism in Latin America,(Oxford: Blackwell Publishers, 1990) 273275.

16D. Martin, Tongues of Fire: Explosion of Protestantism in Latin America,(Oxford: Blackwell Publishers, 1990) 274.

17D. Martin, Tongues of Fire: Explosion of Protestantism in Latin America,(Oxford: Blackwell Publishers, 1990) 278.

18D. Martin, Tongues of Fire: Explosion of Protestantism in Latin America,(Oxford: Blackwell Publishers, 1990) 278.

19D. Martin, Tongues of Fire: Explosion of Protestantism in Latin America,(Oxford: Blackwell Publishers, 1990) 280.

20D. Martin, Tongues of Fire: Explosion of Protestantism in Latin America,(Oxford: Blackwell Publishers, 1990) 280281.

21D. Martin, Tongues of Fire: Explosion of Protestantism in Latin America,(Oxford: Blackwell Publishers, 1990) 281.

22D. Martin, Tongues of Fire: Explosion of Protestantism in Latin America,(Oxford: Blackwell Publishers, 1990) 282283.

23D. Martin, Tongues of Fire: Explosion of Protestantism in Latin America,(Oxford: Blackwell Publishers, 1990) 284.

24D. Martin, Tongues of Fire: Explosion of Protestantism in Latin America,(Oxford: Blackwell Publishers, 1990) 284.

25D. Martin, Tongues of Fire: Explosion of Protestantism in Latin America,(Oxford: Blackwell Publishers, 1990) 284.

26D. Martin, Tongues of Fire: Explosion of Protestantism in Latin America,(Oxford: Blackwell Publishers, 1990) 288.

27D. Martin, Tongues of Fire: Explosion of Protestantism in Latin America,(Oxford: Blackwell Publishers, 1990) 289.

28D. Martin, Tongues of Fire: Explosion of Protestantism in Latin America,(Oxford: Blackwell Publishers, 1990) 289.

29D. Martin, Tongues of Fire: Explosion of Protestantism in Latin America,(Oxford: Blackwell Publishers, 1990) 296.

30D. Martin, Tongues of Fire: Explosion of Protestantism in Latin America,(Oxford: Blackwell Publishers, 1990) 296298.

Smith and Campos

"Perhaps the most influential American televangelists in Brazil have been Jimmy Swaggart, Pat Robertson and Rex Humbard." 1(56)

Swaggart the most significant due to the local support he received from the Assemblies of God 2(56)

o

difficulty for local evangelicals to get resources available for the use of TV media 3(57) Fanini as one of the pioneers in this sense, relationship with then president Figueredo getting him the concession of the Channel 13 in Rio de Janiero for fifteen years from 1983, but unable to muster resources to support this so that: "Fanini's ambitious project stalleD Some years later, beset with debts, he sold his 75% share of Radiodifusao Eheneser Ltd to Edir Macedo, founder and bishop of the Universal Church of the Reign of God (IURD)." 4(57)

o

"Edir Macedo understood early on that Evangelicals would not become major players in Brazilian television until they achieved the financial freedom to be able to make major investments in technology and television licenses. A former member of The New Life Church and a former employee of Rio de Janeiro's state lottery, Macedo began in 1977 to mount his own religious enterprise. " 5(57)


IURD: (1) purchase of Record for $45 million in 1989 and the headquarters and production equipment of TVJovem Pan for $15 million. 6(58)

"Macedo's religious empire includes more than four thousand temples, usually installed in former supermarkets or cinemas, located in large and medium-sized cities throughout the country; he has not been successful in establishing himself in smaller towns. Also included are television and radio stations outside Brazil, the Folha Universal newspaper with a weekly circulation of over 1.5 million, a modern printing plant, a small bank, a tourism business and even a furniture factory that produces benches for his churches."7 (58)

" The services are punctuated by vignettes and jingles that emphasise miracles and attaining concrete results. This message offers solutions to a middle class going through difficult times as well as to the urban poor in search of social ascent." 8(58)

Since 2002, IURD's programming has included rites and imagery taken from Afro-Brazilian religions, especially Umbanda. Macedo frequently stages hybrid exorcisms in which white-robed pastors speak of 'the Father of Lights'. 9(58)

" The screen shows pictures of waterfalls and crashing surf, places intimately tied to African religious traditions. Such discourse provides both explicit and subliminal associations to Afro-Brazilian worship." (58)

"The IURD appropriates and markets a wide variety of religious symbols including holy water, salt, anointing oil, bread and wine, sacred stones, blessed flowers and sacred robes. In addition to borrowing from Afro-Brazilian religious discourse, IURD spectacles incorporate elements of Brazilian Catholicism, Protestantism, and Kardecist Spiritism. These relics are transformed by the touch of the IURD's 'consecrated men of God' into 'blessed means of salvation and healing' and bring 'the heavenly future' to the 'blessed present' while inviting viewers to come to the 'addresses of happiness'. "10(58)

"Key to the IURD's success has been the creation of a highly centralised network of temples, essentially religious franchises, capable of generating a large and reliable flow of cash. Effective resource management has given Macedo the freedom to be able to finance any acquisition or transaction at any time by always having at his disposal at least $5 million in cash." 11(59)

o

"After splitting with Macedo in 1980, his brother-in-law, R.R. Soares, created the first IURD clone, the International Church of God's Grace (IIGD)."12 (59)

"Soares decided on a two-track strategy, negotiating a volume discount for primetime access with Rede Bandeirantes while simultaneously pursuing financial resources to be able to buy his own television channel."13 (59)

Brief reference to the Hernandes and Renascer em Cristo

o

tension between the complexity of religious phenomena and the simplified message demanded by television media "Thus, the earliest producers of evangelistic messages for the electronic media came to conceive of religious conversion in simplified, individualistic terms as demanded by the principles of marketing (Smith, 1990: 296). The great innovation of the Neo-Pentecostal media preachers has been to simplify the message even further, eliminating doctrine and reducing the message to a commercial transaction of symbolic goods." 14(61)

"Confronted with disenchantment, it is not surprising that the televised events and speech found in Latin Americas electronic church, can re-enchant the world and are increasingly popular."15 (61)

o

"The electronic media provide a venue for the approximation between Temple and Marketplace." 16(62)

o

"A new generation of religious entrepreneurs has understood how to tap into the collective spiritual resources of the region, package them in drama, and cloak them in authority and mystery Then they offer them to a populace often wrestling for survival, mired in permanent crisis and

hungry for meaning, hope and a sense of transcendence." 17(62)

"Today it is common to find people in both Brazil and urban Latin America who simultaneously consume televised religious spectacles offered by the megachurches, use amulets or crystals derived from New Age spirituality, seek alternative healing from traditional healers, and consult with Spiritists for orientation in cases of personal crisis. Meanwhile, the traditional churches are losing their historic monopoly on dispensing sacraments, especially as these systems for marketing new spiritualities and mediated symbolic spaces become broadly available. Simultaneously, the power of the traditional churches to stigmatise 'unorthodox' religious belief and practice has been weakened."18 (62)

1D Smith & LS Campos, ' Christianity and Television in Guatemala and Brazil: The Pentecostal Experience', Studies in World Christianity 11:1 (2005), 4964, 56.

2D Smith & LS Campos, ' Christianity and Television in Guatemala and Brazil: The Pentecostal Experience', Studies in World Christianity 11:1 (2005), 4964, 56.

3D Smith & LS Campos, ' Christianity and Television in Guatemala and Brazil: The Pentecostal Experience', Studies in World Christianity 11:1 (2005), 4964, 57.

4D Smith & LS Campos, ' Christianity and Television in Guatemala and Brazil: The Pentecostal Experience', Studies in World Christianity 11:1 (2005), 4964, 57.

5D Smith & LS Campos, ' Christianity and Television in Guatemala and Brazil: The Pentecostal Experience', Studies in World Christianity 11:1 (2005), 4964, 57.

6D Smith & LS Campos, ' Christianity and Television in Guatemala and Brazil: The Pentecostal Experience', Studies in World Christianity 11:1 (2005), 4964, 58.

7D Smith & LS Campos, ' Christianity and Television in Guatemala and Brazil: The Pentecostal Experience', Studies in World Christianity 11:1 (2005), 4964, 58.

8D Smith & LS Campos, ' Christianity and Television in Guatemala and Brazil: The Pentecostal Experience', Studies in World Christianity 11:1 (2005), 4964, 58.

9D Smith & LS Campos, ' Christianity and Television in Guatemala and Brazil: The Pentecostal Experience', Studies in World Christianity 11:1 (2005), 4964, 58.

10D Smith & LS Campos, ' Christianity and Television in Guatemala and Brazil: The Pentecostal Experience', Studies in World Christianity 11:1 (2005), 4964, 58.

11D Smith & LS Campos, ' Christianity and Television in Guatemala and Brazil: The Pentecostal Experience', Studies in World Christianity 11:1 (2005), 4964, 59.

12D Smith & LS Campos, ' Christianity and Television in Guatemala and Brazil: The Pentecostal Experience', Studies in World Christianity 11:1 (2005), 4964, 59.

13D Smith & LS Campos, ' Christianity and Television in Guatemala and Brazil: The Pentecostal Experience', Studies in World Christianity 11:1 (2005), 4964, 59.

14D Smith & LS Campos, ' Christianity and Television in Guatemala and Brazil: The Pentecostal Experience', Studies in World Christianity 11:1 (2005), 4964, 61.

15D Smith & LS Campos, ' Christianity and Television in Guatemala and Brazil: The Pentecostal Experience', Studies in World Christianity 11:1 (2005), 4964, 61.

16D Smith & LS Campos, ' Christianity and Television in Guatemala and Brazil: The Pentecostal Experience', Studies in World Christianity 11:1 (2005), 4964, 62.

17D Smith & LS Campos, ' Christianity and Television in Guatemala and Brazil: The Pentecostal Experience', Studies in World Christianity 11:1 (2005), 4964, 62.

18D Smith & LS Campos, ' Christianity and Television in Guatemala and Brazil: The Pentecostal Experience', Studies in World Christianity 11:1 (2005), 4964, 62.

SImulacro

Describes the ways that those who are possessed are interviewed at the IURD, often in a manner which ridicules them and which author consideres a grotesque imitation of what happens at the terreiros1


Umbanda worship of preto-velhos, caboclos and orixas, Batuque worship only of orixas, quimbanda worship of all including exus and pomba girias2


Stages of discourse within an IURD service (1) Holy Spirit called upon by faithful through words of bishop/pastor.3 (2) Invocatioof evil spirits; author notes how IURD transforms understanding of spirits within ABRs; significance of labelling all spirits as “encostos” which are seen as evil4 (3)

refers to the significance of the “encostos” scream to setting the stage for the dialogue between good and evil.5(4) analysis of the exorcism of spirits and the interview with the most resistant. Whereas in ABRs only those who worship the Orixas are possessed, in the IURD possession is seen to be possible as a result of any contact with the ABRs.6 (5) concluding moment of quiet and peace, healing and deliverance declared, ends with bishop/pastor blessing the lives of those who have been delivered.7


M Tadvald, “O Simulacro da Alteridade em Perspectiva: Comentários acerca de uma Análise Discursiva de um Ritual da Igreja Universal” Debates do NER 6:7 (2005), 89–97.


Suggests that some may wish to manifest “encostos” in an IURD session to overcome anonymity of low social status, likens to poor youth who commit crime as a form of social projection.8


refers to the case of “Mae Gilda” accused of being a charlatan by IURD. Terreiro invaded by evangelicals wishing to carry out exorcism. R$ 960,000 paid as compensation to her family, after her death.9


AL Jungblut, “O Mal e os Malvados: As Crenças Polidemonistas na Igreja Universal do Reino de Deus” Debates do NER 6:7 (2005), 125–133.


criticises those who see spiritual warfare as an IURD innovation, demonstrating that it is prevalent across the evangelical spectrum in Brazil and in the world.10

emphasises that IURD is not only antagonistic against ABRs but also Catholicism, spiritism and New Age. Catholic saints and New Age avatars also demonised.11


points out that conflict with ABRs is significant only in Brazil, in other countries antagonism is with spiritual entities recognised in that context.12


Sees in the IURD an importation of the concept of territorial spirits; IURD differs from IIGD in not recognising/acknowledging foreign influence.13 claims polidemonismo in IURD reflects Territorial Spirits doctrine; critiques Ribeiro for not distinguishing discourse about demons from discourse about the devil.14


AP Oro, “A Demonologia da Igreja Universal do Reino de Deus” Debates do NER 6:7 (2005), 135–146.


IURD demonology: Christian tradition+ ABR influence15

decline of the role of the devil in official Catholicism in 20th century; figure retained in popular Catholicism16

in IURD demons seen as the source of all evils17

demonizing of mediunic religions, IURD takes further and radicalizes something already present in Catholicism and other evangelical churches.18 significance of offensive approach rather than defensive.19

links demonology of IURD with a global trend of increased belief in the demonic. Sees this as a reflection of (1) decline of institutional religion (2) sense of impotency in the modern world (3) demonization of the other.20

1J Ribeiro, “O Simulacro da Alteridade: Uma Análise Discursiva do Ritual de Exorcismo da Igreja Universal do Reino de Deus” Debates do NER 6:7 (2005), 11–78, 13.

2J Ribeiro, “O Simulacro da Alteridade: Uma Análise Discursiva do Ritual de Exorcismo da Igreja Universal do Reino de Deus” Debates do NER 6:7 (2005), 11–78, 26 note 7.

3J Ribeiro, “O Simulacro da Alteridade: Uma Análise Discursiva do Ritual de Exorcismo da Igreja Universal do Reino de Deus” Debates do NER 6:7 (2005), 11–78, 2732.

4J Ribeiro, “O Simulacro da Alteridade: Uma Análise Discursiva do Ritual de Exorcismo da Igreja Universal do Reino de Deus” Debates do NER 6:7 (2005), 11–78, 3248.

5J Ribeiro, “O Simulacro da Alteridade: Uma Análise Discursiva do Ritual de Exorcismo da Igreja Universal do Reino de Deus” Debates do NER 6:7 (2005), 11–78, 52.

6J Ribeiro, “O Simulacro da Alteridade: Uma Análise Discursiva do Ritual de Exorcismo da Igreja Universal do Reino de Deus” Debates do NER 6:7 (2005), 11–78, 5262.

7J Ribeiro, “O Simulacro da Alteridade: Uma Análise Discursiva do Ritual de Exorcismo da Igreja Universal do Reino de Deus” Debates do NER 6:7 (2005), 11–78, 6271.

8M Tadvald, “O Simulacro da Alteridade em Perspectiva: Comentários acerca de uma Análise Discursiva de um Ritual da Igreja Universal” Debates do NER 6:7 (2005), 89–97, 9495.

9M Tadvald, “O Simulacro da Alteridade em Perspectiva: Comentários acerca de uma Análise Discursiva de um Ritual da Igreja Universal” Debates do NER 6:7 (2005), 89–97, 96.

10AL Jungblut, “O Mal e os Malvados: As Crenças Polidemonistas na Igreja Universal do Reino de Deus” Debates do NER 6:7 (2005), 125–133, 125126.

11AL Jungblut, “O Mal e os Malvados: As Crenças Polidemonistas na Igreja Universal do Reino de Deus” Debates do NER 6:7 (2005), 125–133, 126127.

12AL Jungblut, “O Mal e os Malvados: As Crenças Polidemonistas na Igreja Universal do Reino de Deus” Debates do NER 6:7 (2005), 125–133, 127128.

13AL Jungblut, “O Mal e os Malvados: As Crenças Polidemonistas na Igreja Universal do Reino de Deus” Debates do NER 6:7 (2005), 125–133, 128129.

14AL Jungblut, “O Mal e os Malvados: As Crenças Polidemonistas na Igreja Universal do Reino de Deus” Debates do NER 6:7 (2005), 125–133, 130132.

15AP Oro, “A Demonologia da Igreja Universal do Reino de Deus” Debates do NER 6:7 (2005), 135–146, 135.

16AP Oro, “A Demonologia da Igreja Universal do Reino de Deus” Debates do NER 6:7 (2005), 135–146, 137.

17AP Oro, “A Demonologia da Igreja Universal do Reino de Deus” Debates do NER 6:7 (2005), 135–146, 138.

18AP Oro, “A Demonologia da Igreja Universal do Reino de Deus” Debates do NER 6:7 (2005), 135–146, 138139.

19AP Oro, “A Demonologia da Igreja Universal do Reino de Deus” Debates do NER 6:7 (2005), 135–146, 141142.

20AP Oro, “A Demonologia da Igreja Universal do Reino de Deus” Debates do NER 6:7 (2005), 135–146, 142145.

Rees

"The resulting transformation of Latin American nations from missionary-receivers to missionary-senders is also well documented, and the practical effects of this are felt in the growing number of Latin – particularly Brazilian – Protestant missionaries spread across the globe."1 (1)

o

"The vitality of any Christian movement has to be seen in its long-term durability, the depth of influence it holds within the Christian population it draws on, its theological maturity, and its creative ability to overcome the inevitable obstacles that it encounters. Certainly as far as Latin America is concerned (I am not familiar with how other non-western missionary movements fare in this respect, and thus cannot comment) much is still left to be desired." 2(1)

o

"I have consistently been surprised how American (i.e. North American) the churches in Latin America are...nevertheless, the Americanisation of Latin American Protestant Christianity is a remarkable phenomenon of cultural transformation... certain trends of “successful” North American Christianity – size of congregation, ambitious building programmes, a conservative socio-political agenda – have been transplanted into the heart of Latin American evangelicalism."

Links this with the dominance of the faith missions model3 (1)

o

claims that the faith-mission model has problems in Latin America

(1) Lack of strong economic conditions which make it viable

(2) Lack of a calvinistic work ethic which ensure that pledges will not be easily forgotten or transferred to another cause 4(2)

o

"A good number of missionaries have been sent out, albeit with considerable economic difficulties in many cases. The financial insecurity involved has led to a premature return for many – too many – and condemned others to a permanent state of suspense, awaiting the Damocles’ sword of unfulfilled financial pledges to fall. And this is not to mention those who have been unable to go because of lack of finance, the thousands who will want to be sent in years to come, or those in my own mission who have been trained but cannot find even adequate “promises.”"5 (3)

o

"At some point, we need to realise that the concept of “supported missionaries” is ultimately a modern and western phenomenon and cannot be made into the mainstay of contemporary non-western mission strategy." 6(3)

o

" Latin American missions will only “take off” when initiative for its financing is put back into the hands of its protagonists, the missionaries themselves. Rather than being taught to wait for an elusive handout, successful missionaries will be prepared – through secular training too – to work their way to the nations. To avoid visa difficulties, appropriate career choices will need to be made in accordance with the particular needs of the regions where different ones are destined. And missionary recruitment must present this reality, rather than simply inspiring people with visions of the unreached. All this must become part of Latin American missionary strategy, actively and diligently researched and applied by mission leaders and analysts, rather than simply left to chance or individual prerogative."7(4)

o

"Looking at missions to the old world, Europe, it is inconceivable for most Latin American churches to even imagine providing the £10,000 plus a year needed to keep a missionary family in most of Europe today. Yet with nearly half a million Ecuadorians, for example, living in Spain, there surely is another way. If even 5% of these Ecuadorians are evangelical believers, then there are now some 24,000 potential extra witnesses to Christ in Spain." 8(4)"

o

"Space does not permit entering into a discussion of the ethics of entering Europe as illegal immigrants – suffice it to say that many ask God’s blessing on their attempts to get here, and those who have to balance the books for Europe’s ageing social security system are heard to mutter a loud “Amen.” History is the story of the flow of peoples across the face of the globe, and more often than not the gospel – not to mention other ideologies – has travelled with these movements of people. Contemporary Latin American missionary strategy will not be complete without entering this arena.

We thus cannot continue to attempt to raise Latin missionaries for Europe with scarcely any reference to the massive immigration that is taking place across the continent. Beyond attempting to harness existing immigrants, there is also a place for raising a new workforce of committed and called missionaries, who will minister in Europe from the role of economic refugees. Adequate pre-field training, prayer support from home churches, preparation and co-ordination of placements, and on-field support and supervision should all be taken into serious consideration, just as much as for “full-time” workers in any other part of the world." 9(4)

o

"Pastoral leadership in the sending church still considers the worker to all intents and purposes a member of that church, ultimately under its authority, and the workers themselves will share this perspective."10 (5)

o

"The results for overseas workers of this dichotomy of identity and points of reference are numerous. I have witnessed its effects in terms of lack of stability for long-term work, confusion over the source of authority for decisions relating to local ministry, the imposition of foreign denominations or liturgical forms, unavailability of adequate member care and culturally sensitive advice, tensions in relationships with existing evangelical expressions (particularly of the same denomination) and in some instances the discrediting of the whole missionary enterprise in the eyes of the church and the abandonment of any ongoing commitment to cross-cultural missions." 11(5)

o

"Whilst not totally absent, theological reflection on the nature of the cross-cultural missionary task before the Latin American evangelical church, and how to equip its agents to fulfil this mandate, has yet to appear with force."12 (5)

o

"transformation, and dismissing the whole lot as “of the devil,” few missionaries are in fact prepared for dialogue with convinced devotees of other religions. Superficial evangelistic “chat-up” lines, which (perhaps!) suffice in a nominally Christian culture, cannot be transported for use with people of long-standing non-Christian traditions. In order to offer a challenging, relevant and ultimately credible witness, essentially non-biblical notions such as “inviting Jesus into one’s heart” must surrender to a more biblical and culturally intelligible message."13 (5-6)

1 N Rees, 'The Search for a Creative Response to Obstacles to the Growth of Mission out of Latin America', Encounters 10 (2006), 1 [available redcliffe site]

2 N Rees, 'The Search for a Creative Response to Obstacles to the Growth of Mission out of Latin America', Encounters 10 (2006), 1 [available redcliffe site]

3 N Rees, 'The Search for a Creative Response to Obstacles to the Growth of Mission out of Latin America', Encounters 10 (2006), 1 [available redcliffe site]

4 N Rees, 'The Search for a Creative Response to Obstacles to the Growth of Mission out of Latin America', Encounters 10 (2006), 2 [available redcliffe site]

5 N Rees, 'The Search for a Creative Response to Obstacles to the Growth of Mission out of Latin America', Encounters 10 (2006), 3 [available redcliffe site]

6 N Rees, 'The Search for a Creative Response to Obstacles to the Growth of Mission out of Latin America', Encounters 10 (2006), 3 [available redcliffe site]

7 N Rees, 'The Search for a Creative Response to Obstacles to the Growth of Mission out of Latin America', Encounters 10 (2006), 4 [available redcliffe site]

8 N Rees, 'The Search for a Creative Response to Obstacles to the Growth of Mission out of Latin America', Encounters 10 (2006), 4 [available redcliffe site]

9 N Rees, 'The Search for a Creative Response to Obstacles to the Growth of Mission out of Latin America', Encounters 10 (2006), 4 [available redcliffe site]

10 N Rees, 'The Search for a Creative Response to Obstacles to the Growth of Mission out of Latin America', Encounters 10 (2006), 5 [available redcliffe site]

11 N Rees, 'The Search for a Creative Response to Obstacles to the Growth of Mission out of Latin America', Encounters 10 (2006), 5 [available redcliffe site]

12 N Rees, 'The Search for a Creative Response to Obstacles to the Growth of Mission out of Latin America', Encounters 10 (2006), 5 [available redcliffe site]

13 N Rees, 'The Search for a Creative Response to Obstacles to the Growth of Mission out of Latin America', Encounters 10 (2006), 56 [available redcliffe site]

pereira

condemns a spirituality of the market place 1(92)

"Our theologies and pastoral policies are tired and exhausted. The economic system has taken over Western religious language, leaving more or less generous margins for the churches that have before them the easiest option, which is to become an integral functional part of the whole package presented by capitalism, offering religious goods as commodities, and services in the form of powerful fundamentalisms and charismatic spectacles of marketing and prosperity." 2(94)

"Throughout the world young theologians are silenced by a dominant North American and European theological model that is weary of becoming good news, that is cosying up to the knowledge industry in the service of an economic model which gives privileged place to its comfortable, stable consumerist societies." 3(97)

1NC Pereira, 'Empire and Religion: Gospel, Ecumenism and Prophecy for the 21st Century', The Ecumenical Review 58:1 (2006), 9298, 92.

2NC Pereira, 'Empire and Religion: Gospel, Ecumenism and Prophecy for the 21st Century', The Ecumenical Review 58:1 (2006), 9298, 94.

3NC Pereira, 'Empire and Religion: Gospel, Ecumenism and Prophecy for the 21st Century', The Ecumenical Review 58:1 (2006), 9298, 97.

Steunargel

points to the initial foreign influenced approach to studying theology in Brazil and how this has collapsed, often due to financial restraints 1(203-205)

Latin American critique of Western theology necessary, but too often "narrow tools of interpretation" e.g. oppressor vs. oppressed were used 2(205)

Western presuppositions brought to Latin American theological study:

(1) Christian faith understood in Cartesian terms in an academic environment

(2) use of scientific methods focusing on evidence, consistency.

(3) possibility of objective study

(4) separation study of theology exercise of ministry yet to study theology led to becoming part of the professional clergy3(206)

multiplication of seminaries without contextual experimentation 4(206)

celebrates growth of Latin American church, and its missionary passion especially the way it is "moving fast into the worldwide missionary community." 5(206) yet "this church has not done well in terms of doing theology or shaping theological education." 6(206)

Liberation theology as a sign of despair, offering an illusory solution 7(207)

Theological advance, questioning the package which came from the North8 (207)

Ideological, excluding those who did not "embrace the package" creating "a pedagogy of conflict that made it quite difficult to work in a democratic environment and according tot he democratic rules...did not form people for belonging to an open society or for building Christian communities" 9(208)

claims that Lib. The "disappeared quite quickly from the horizon of theological education. While continuing here and there the excitement was gone and its captivating effect had vanished."10 (208)

in a footnote suggest that the impetus has moved to (1) macro-ecumenism (2) some ecological concerns (3) aim at conquering political power within institutional churches. 11(207 n.1)

o

Brazilian evangelical growth:

dynamism, creativity, initiative, pragmatism, experimentation, mixture and syncretism12 (209)

despite prosperity theology and excesses in spiritual warfare, celebrates the number of people coming to know Christ 13(210)

4 concerns raised:

1. excessive experimentation and promises brings "big shadows over the credibility of the gospel and are producing too many victims in the name of the Lord...Some early data seem to show that in those same areas where the church is growing most, the number of people who declare themselves non-believers is growing."14 (210)

2. lack of concern for the consequences in the next generation15 (210)

3. loss of capital of credibility through ethical problems16 (210-211)

4. lack of impact on poverty and social inequality 17(211)


1V Steurnagel, ' The Relevance and Effects of European Academic Theology on Theological Education in the Third World', The Evangelical Review of Theology 27:3 (2003), 203212, 203205.

2V Steurnagel, ' The Relevance and Effects of European Academic Theology on Theological Education in the Third World', The Evangelical Review of Theology 27:3 (2003), 203212, 205.

3V Steurnagel, ' The Relevance and Effects of European Academic Theology on Theological Education in the Third World', The Evangelical Review of Theology 27:3 (2003), 203212, 206.

4V Steurnagel, ' The Relevance and Effects of European Academic Theology on Theological Education in the Third World', The Evangelical Review of Theology 27:3 (2003), 203212, 206.

5V Steurnagel, ' The Relevance and Effects of European Academic Theology on Theological Education in the Third World', The Evangelical Review of Theology 27:3 (2003), 203212, 206.

6V Steurnagel, ' The Relevance and Effects of European Academic Theology on Theological Education in the Third World', The Evangelical Review of Theology 27:3 (2003), 203212, 206.

7V Steurnagel, ' The Relevance and Effects of European Academic Theology on Theological Education in the Third World', The Evangelical Review of Theology 27:3 (2003), 203212, 207.

8V Steurnagel, ' The Relevance and Effects of European Academic Theology on Theological Education in the Third World', The Evangelical Review of Theology 27:3 (2003), 203212, 207.

9V Steurnagel, ' The Relevance and Effects of European Academic Theology on Theological Education in the Third World', The Evangelical Review of Theology 27:3 (2003), 203212, 208.

10V Steurnagel, ' The Relevance and Effects of European Academic Theology on Theological Education in the Third World', The Evangelical Review of Theology 27:3 (2003), 203212, 208.

11V Steurnagel, ' The Relevance and Effects of European Academic Theology on Theological Education in the Third World', The Evangelical Review of Theology 27:3 (2003), 203212, 207 footnote 1.

12V Steurnagel, ' The Relevance and Effects of European Academic Theology on Theological Education in the Third World', The Evangelical Review of Theology 27:3 (2003), 203212, 209.

13V Steurnagel, ' The Relevance and Effects of European Academic Theology on Theological Education in the Third World', The Evangelical Review of Theology 27:3 (2003), 203212, 210.

14V Steurnagel, ' The Relevance and Effects of European Academic Theology on Theological Education in the Third World', The Evangelical Review of Theology 27:3 (2003), 203212, 210.

15V Steurnagel, ' The Relevance and Effects of European Academic Theology on Theological Education in the Third World', The Evangelical Review of Theology 27:3 (2003), 203212, 210.

16V Steurnagel, ' The Relevance and Effects of European Academic Theology on Theological Education in the Third World', The Evangelical Review of Theology 27:3 (2003), 203212, 210211.

17V Steurnagel, ' The Relevance and Effects of European Academic Theology on Theological Education in the Third World', The Evangelical Review of Theology 27:3 (2003), 203212, 211.

Alvarez

"Latin American Pentecostals are large, self-supporting, self-governed and self-multiplying churches." 1(140)

"twenty-first century Pentecostals face problems of leadership, education, division and social alienation." 2(140)

refers to the significance of background knowledge acquired through Roman Catholicism3 (141)

refers to the acceptance of the supernatural 4(141)

For Pentecostals "the Catholic Church also represents, in their mind, an agent of alienation, oppression and compromise with the demonic powers of the world." 5(142)

refers to the importance of lay participation in the structures of the church 6(143)

"the problem of numerical growth without proper biblical teaching and discipleship. In some ares, they also tend to center too much power in authoritarian leaders." 7(145) danger of an "artificial spirituality"8 (145)

perceives the dangers of a growing secularism and materialism 9(146) danger of North American imports 10(146)

fears the danger of a new and triumphalist Pentecostal subculture 11(146)

Escobar's reasons for growth in Latin America:

(1) Spiritual facts (2) Anthropological reasons--hunger for God (3) Sociological elements, providing identity, shelter, security and community (4) Pastoral methodology: lay participation

(5) Psychologican and cultural factors --freedom of worship, use of folk music 12(148)

refers to an estimate of 3000 Pentecostal Missionaries sent from Latin America 13(149)

links prosperity theology with the process of secularization 14(152-153)

1M Alvarez, 'The South and the Latin American Paradigm of the Pentecostal Movement', Asia Journal of Pentecostal Studies 5:1 (2002), 135153, 140.

2M Alvarez, 'The South and the Latin American Paradigm of the Pentecostal Movement', Asia Journal of Pentecostal Studies 5:1 (2002), 135153, 140.

3M Alvarez, 'The South and the Latin American Paradigm of the Pentecostal Movement', Asia Journal of Pentecostal Studies 5:1 (2002), 135153, 141.

4M Alvarez, 'The South and the Latin American Paradigm of the Pentecostal Movement', Asia Journal of Pentecostal Studies 5:1 (2002), 135153, 141.

5M Alvarez, 'The South and the Latin American Paradigm of the Pentecostal Movement', Asia Journal of Pentecostal Studies 5:1 (2002), 135153, 142.

6M Alvarez, 'The South and the Latin American Paradigm of the Pentecostal Movement', Asia Journal of Pentecostal Studies 5:1 (2002), 135153, 143.

7M Alvarez, 'The South and the Latin American Paradigm of the Pentecostal Movement', Asia Journal of Pentecostal Studies 5:1 (2002), 135153, 145.

8M Alvarez, 'The South and the Latin American Paradigm of the Pentecostal Movement', Asia Journal of Pentecostal Studies 5:1 (2002), 135153, 145.

9M Alvarez, 'The South and the Latin American Paradigm of the Pentecostal Movement', Asia Journal of Pentecostal Studies 5:1 (2002), 135153, 146.

10M Alvarez, 'The South and the Latin American Paradigm of the Pentecostal Movement', Asia Journal of Pentecostal Studies 5:1 (2002), 135153, 146.

11M Alvarez, 'The South and the Latin American Paradigm of the Pentecostal Movement', Asia Journal of Pentecostal Studies 5:1 (2002), 135153, 146.

12M Alvarez, 'The South and the Latin American Paradigm of the Pentecostal Movement', Asia Journal of Pentecostal Studies 5:1 (2002), 135153, 148.

13M Alvarez, 'The South and the Latin American Paradigm of the Pentecostal Movement', Asia Journal of Pentecostal Studies 5:1 (2002), 135153, 149.

14M Alvarez, 'The South and the Latin American Paradigm of the Pentecostal Movement', Asia Journal of Pentecostal Studies 5:1 (2002), 135153, 152153.

Weaver

16th century, failure of Calvinist misison. 17th century failure of Dutch (protestant) invasion 1(447)


1824 constitution gave freedom of religion 2(448)


success of freemasons and Positivists in the Post-Independence period3 (448-449)


Southern immigrants...set up churches...centres served as bases 4(449)


19th century, eventual failure of Methodist missions under Spaulding and Kidder but their writings gave impetus to immigration. 5449-451)


For Southerners, despite Catholic dominance "Brazil with its vast land spaces and acceptance of slavery seemed the ideal haven." 6(452)


Freedom of religion in Brazil far more restricted than Southerners expectations 7(453)


initial missionary project linked to the need to cater for the spiritual needs of Southerners in Brazil yet this acted as a springboard for ministry to the natives, not least through the establishing of schools 8(454-457)

conflict between Rome and Masons seen to open door for missions 9(461)

focuses on the Development of Methodists in Brazil 10458-461)

Baptist churches among confederates in Brazil, and link to the opening of the first Brazilian Baptist Churches 11(465-466)


1B Weaver, “Confederate Immigrants and Evangelical Churches in Brazil,” The Journal of Southern History 18:5 (1952), 446468, 447.

2B Weaver, “Confederate Immigrants and Evangelical Churches in Brazil,” The Journal of Southern History 18:5 (1952), 446468, 448.

3B Weaver, “Confederate Immigrants and Evangelical Churches in Brazil,” The Journal of Southern History 18:5 (1952), 446468, 448449.

4B Weaver, “Confederate Immigrants and Evangelical Churches in Brazil,” The Journal of Southern History 18:5 (1952), 446468, 449.

5B Weaver, “Confederate Immigrants and Evangelical Churches in Brazil,” The Journal of Southern History 18:5 (1952), 446468, 449451.

6B Weaver, “Confederate Immigrants and Evangelical Churches in Brazil,” The Journal of Southern History 18:5 (1952), 446468, 452.

7B Weaver, “Confederate Immigrants and Evangelical Churches in Brazil,” The Journal of Southern History 18:5 (1952), 446468, 453.

8B Weaver, “Confederate Immigrants and Evangelical Churches in Brazil,” The Journal of Southern History 18:5 (1952), 446468, 454457.

9B Weaver, “Confederate Immigrants and Evangelical Churches in Brazil,” The Journal of Southern History 18:5 (1952), 446468, 461.

10B Weaver, “Confederate Immigrants and Evangelical Churches in Brazil,” The Journal of Southern History 18:5 (1952), 446468, 458461.

11B Weaver, “Confederate Immigrants and Evangelical Churches in Brazil,” The Journal of Southern History 18:5 (1952), 446468, 465466.

Mallaprandi

"Some are inclined to view the rapid expansion of Christianity as a reproduction of the “American gospel” abroad. This is most evident in the use of megacrusades and the growth of megachurches in places such as Nigeria, South Korea, and Brazil, as well as in the conflation of Protestantism with modernization,telecommunications, corporate dollars, and nationalism."1 (10)

"Recent projects, largely grounded in political science, more subtly locate global Christianity within an essentially American story. They have examined the church’s role in facilitating certain “transitions” within Third World societies—for example, transitions out of both colonialism and authoritarian nationalism into the growth of civil society, multiparty systems, and other democratic reforms."2 (10)

1C Mallampalli, 'World Christianity and "Protestant America": Historical Narratives and the Limits of Christian Pluralism', International Bulletin of Missionary Research 30:1 (2006), 813, 10.

2C Mallampalli, 'World Christianity and "Protestant America": Historical Narratives and the Limits of Christian Pluralism', International Bulletin of Missionary Research 30:1 (2006), 813, 10.

Escobar

Southern Christianity= popular/ grassroots Christianity1 (12-13) "marked by a culture of poverty, an oral liturgy, narrative preaching, uninhibited emotionalism, maximum participation in prayer and worship, dreams and visions, faith healing, and an intense search for community and belonging 2(13)

"Probably there has been no point at which missionary action and imperial action have been so closely linked in theory and practice as in the evangelization of the AmericaS" 3(46)


more ambiguous relationship between empire and missions in the case of Protestant mission 4(48)

Latin American---protestant mission came at a time of British support for the independence of colonies (549)

American missionaries often don't perceive their work as linked to American expansion, the same is not to be said of those who receive them 6(50)

importance of voluntarism and student movements in American mission7 (49-51)

"The estimated number of missionaries sent from Latin America had risen from 820 in 1972 to 1,127 in 1980 to 3,026 in 1988. The most recent study available shows that by 1997 there were 284 Protestant sending agencies and a total of 3,921 missionaries in Latin America." 8(166)

1S Escobar,A Time for Mission: The Challenge for Global Christianity, The Global Christian Library, (Leicester: InterVarsity Press: 2003) 1213.

2S Escobar,A Time for Mission: The Challenge for Global Christianity, The Global Christian Library, (Leicester: InterVarsity Press: 2003) 13.

3S Escobar,A Time for Mission: The Challenge for Global Christianity, The Global Christian Library, (Leicester: InterVarsity Press: 2003) 46.

4S Escobar,A Time for Mission: The Challenge for Global Christianity, The Global Christian Library, (Leicester: InterVarsity Press: 2003) 48.

5S Escobar,A Time for Mission: The Challenge for Global Christianity, The Global Christian Library, (Leicester: InterVarsity Press: 2003) 49.

6S Escobar,A Time for Mission: The Challenge for Global Christianity, The Global Christian Library, (Leicester: InterVarsity Press: 2003) 50.

7S Escobar,A Time for Mission: The Challenge for Global Christianity, The Global Christian Library, (Leicester: InterVarsity Press: 2003) 4951.

8S Escobar, A Time for Mission: The Challenge for Global Christianity, The Global Christian Library, (Leicester: InterVarsity Press: 2003) 166.