Wednesday, 22 October 2008

Dustmann

Large proportion of working immigrants are recent arrivals, 8% arrived in the last year, one third in the last 10.1
points to an increasing diversity in the country of origin of immigrants.2
“He ¯nds that immigrants are more likely to be self-employed than UK-born individuals with similar levels of skills. Borjas explains these results with what he calls enclave effects: Immigrants create enclaves by concentrating in geographical areas. Such enclaves then provide self-employment opportunities for other members of the respective national group. In these enclaves UK-born individuals lack knowledge of language and preferences of potential customers and have therefore a disadvantage when competing for the same self-employment opportunities.”3

“When computing the effect of language prffciency on the employment and wage gap between UK-born individuals and ethnic minority immigrants, the study concludes that lan-guage largely reduces differences in both economic outcomes.”4

claim that it is difficult to quantify the impact of immigration on the employment and wages of the resident population (1) on unemployment no clear evidence of adverse effect, some indication of increased unemployment but so small to be statistically insignificant (2) on wages, some indication of higher wages.5
1C Dustmann, F Fabri, I Preston & J Wadsworth, Labour Market Performance of Immigrants in the UK Labour Market, Home Office Online Report 05/03 available online at www.homeoffice.gov.uk/rds/pdfs2/rdsolr0503.pdf 19.
2C Dustmann, F Fabri, I Preston & J Wadsworth, Labour Market Performance of Immigrants in the UK Labour Market, Home Office Online Report 05/03 available online at www.homeoffice.gov.uk/rds/pdfs2/rdsolr0503.pdf 19–20.
3C Dustmann, F Fabri, I Preston & J Wadsworth, Labour Market Performance of Immigrants in the UK Labour Market, Home Office Online Report 05/03 available online at www.homeoffice.gov.uk/rds/pdfs2/rdsolr0503.pdf, 41.
4C Dustmann, F Fabri, I Preston & J Wadsworth, Labour Market Performance of Immigrants in the UK Labour Market, Home Office Online Report 05/03 available online at www.homeoffice.gov.uk/rds/pdfs2/rdsolr0503.pdf, 57.
5C Dustmann, F Fabri, I Preston & J Wadsworth, The Local Labour Market Effects of Immigration in the UK, Home Office Online Report 06/03 available online at www.homeoffice.gov.uk/rds/pdfs2/rdsolr0603.p , 4–7.

Dench

Makes the point that a worker in a low-skilled job is not necessarily low skilled themselves.1 Points system to simplify the 50 ways one can enter the UK to work and study into one manageable system.2
explanation of current work permit scheme.3
EU enlargement seen to reduce the need for non-EEA migration of low skilled workers.4
students the largest category of people entering the UK eligible to work.5
reasons for hiring migrants 1) fill vacancies 2) willingness to work outside of regular hours 3) reputation for being hard working and efficient (esp. illegals)6
concentration of migrants in low-skilled jobs linked to the likelihood that they would stay.7
despite (or maybe because of?) tensions, migrant workers help to increase productivity of other workers.8
“Other respondents had experience of Brazilians masquerading as Portuguese, who were also exposed by fellow workers. It was commented that Portuguese can tell the difference between fellow expatriates and Brazilians, and that they resent these impostors.”9
exploitation of illegal migrants 1) lower pay 2) same pay but larger deductions (e.g. Accomodation costs) 3) long hours.10
difficulty for migrant workers to open accounts, many are charged by third-parties to allow access to accounts.11
1S Dench, J Hurtsfield, D Hill & K Akroyd, Employers' Use of Migrant Labour: Main Report, Home Office Online Report 04/06, available online at www.homeoffice.gov.uk/rds/pdfs06/rdsolr0406.pdf [Accessed October 16 2008] 2.
2S Dench, J Hurtsfield, D Hill & K Akroyd, Employers' Use of Migrant Labour: Main Report, Home Office Online Report 04/06, available online at www.homeoffice.gov.uk/rds/pdfs06/rdsolr0406.pdf [Accessed October 16 2008] 2.
3S Dench, J Hurtsfield, D Hill & K Akroyd, Employers' Use of Migrant Labour: Main Report, Home Office Online Report 04/06, available online at www.homeoffice.gov.uk/rds/pdfs06/rdsolr0406.pdf [Accessed October 16 2008] 4.
4S Dench, J Hurtsfield, D Hill & K Akroyd, Employers' Use of Migrant Labour: Main Report, Home Office Online Report 04/06, available online at www.homeoffice.gov.uk/rds/pdfs06/rdsolr0406.pdf [Accessed October 16 2008] 5.
5S Dench, J Hurtsfield, D Hill & K Akroyd, Employers' Use of Migrant Labour: Main Report, Home Office Online Report 04/06, available online at www.homeoffice.gov.uk/rds/pdfs06/rdsolr0406.pdf [Accessed October 16 2008] 14.
6S Dench, J Hurtsfield, D Hill & K Akroyd, Employers' Use of Migrant Labour: Main Report, Home Office Online Report 04/06, available online at www.homeoffice.gov.uk/rds/pdfs06/rdsolr0406.pdf [Accessed October 16 2008] 16–17.
7S Dench, J Hurtsfield, D Hill & K Akroyd, Employers' Use of Migrant Labour: Main Report, Home Office Online Report 04/06, available online at www.homeoffice.gov.uk/rds/pdfs06/rdsolr0406.pdf [Accessed October 16 2008] 25.
8S Dench, J Hurtsfield, D Hill & K Akroyd, Employers' Use of Migrant Labour: Main Report, Home Office Online Report 04/06, available online at www.homeoffice.gov.uk/rds/pdfs06/rdsolr0406.pdf [Accessed October 16 2008] 35.
9S Dench, J Hurtsfield, D Hill & K Akroyd, Employers' Use of Migrant Labour: Main Report, Home Office Online Report 04/06, available online at www.homeoffice.gov.uk/rds/pdfs06/rdsolr0406.pdf [Accessed October 16 2008] 62.
10S Dench, J Hurtsfield, D Hill & K Akroyd, Employers' Use of Migrant Labour: Main Report, Home Office Online Report 04/06, available online at www.homeoffice.gov.uk/rds/pdfs06/rdsolr0406.pdf [Accessed October 16 2008] 63.
11S Dench, J Hurtsfield, D Hill & K Akroyd, Employers' Use of Migrant Labour: Main Report, Home Office Online Report 04/06, available online at www.homeoffice.gov.uk/rds/pdfs06/rdsolr0406.pdf [Accessed October 16 2008] 64.s

Colley et al

Built upon a year long research by Gott and Johnston (Home Office) but increase it to cover a 5 year period. Also rather than comment on the net value of immigrants, compare relative contribution of migrants and non-migrants. Re typical objections 1) It is wrong to assign cost of immigration services to immigrants themselves as much of the rational of the Immigration system is to benefit UK population not immigrants...

“A simple example illustrates the problems inherent in apportioning the entire cost of the immigration system to immigrants themselves: if the government were to operate a ‘closed-door’ policy towards immigration (that is to say, not allow anyone enter the country on a permanent basis) then the costs of policing such a system would be enormous, but there would be no immigrants to assign this cost to. Conversely, if the government were to operate an ‘open-door’policy, then the costs are likely to fall while immigration may increase. Some of the costs of administering the immigration system (such as the employment of immigration officials at ports and airports) are unlikely to fall significantly even with reductions of immigration levels. On the other hand, some of the variable costs of the system are increasingly being recovered through user-charging of migrants and their prospective employers (through fees for work permits). This means that second-guessing which portion of the immigration system is for the benefit of the UK-born and which part is for immigrants is a difficult and potentially futile exercise.”1

Re issue of pension costs of migrants, this ignores that much contemporary migration is temporary in nature.2 3) re: issue of pressure on public services, reminder that migrants are disproportionately represented in the provision of public services.3

NAFI (net annual fiscal contribution, i.e. What is paid in taxes- what is received from government)
Immigrants>UK population. Hence, when there is a budget surplus, immigrants contribute more than UK population, when there is a budget deficit, immigrants receive less.4 (not commented in the paper, but this would be even more accentuated in those groups where there are little if no asylum seekers, thus Brazilians, for asylum seekers are not allowed to work, and thus pay tax, yet receive limited benefits)
1D Sriskandarajah, L Cooley & H Reed, Paying their Way: The Fiscal Contributions of Immigrants in the UK, (London: IPPR, 2008) 6.
2D Sriskandarajah, L Cooley & H Reed, Paying their Way: The Fiscal Contributions of Immigrants in the UK, (London: IPPR, 2008) 7.
3D Sriskandarajah, L Cooley & H Reed, Paying their Way: The Fiscal Contributions of Immigrants in the UK, (London: IPPR, 2008) 7.
4D Sriskandarajah, L Cooley & H Reed, Paying their Way: The Fiscal Contributions of Immigrants in the UK, (London: IPPR, 2008) 12.
c

Coheb

“controls can never be 'fair' to those subject to them. Nor can they ever be 'humane', in that the inevitable end game of all immigration control is forced, compulsory removal accompanied by the threat or actuality of legally sanctioned violence.”1
talks of a general system of immigration control in which workers in the medical and social sectors are conscripted to participate in.2
“immigration control can never have a benevolent face.”3
defends the “full restoration of all benefits and the end of all controls.” (Note this is in the context of asylum seeking)4
1S Cohen, “Breaking the Links and Pulling the Plug” in D Hayes and B Humphries (eds) , Social Work, Immigration and Asylum, (London: Jessica Kingsley, 2004) 7–10, 8.
2S Cohen, “Breaking the Links and Pulling the Plug” in D Hayes and B Humphries (eds) , Social Work, Immigration and Asylum, (London: Jessica Kingsley, 2004) 7–10, 8.
3S Cohen, “Breaking the Links and Pulling the Plug” in D Hayes and B Humphries (eds) , Social Work, Immigration and Asylum, (London: Jessica Kingsley, 2004) 7–10, 9.
4S Cohen, “Breaking the Links and Pulling the Plug” in D Hayes and B Humphries (eds) , Social Work, Immigration and Asylum, (London: Jessica Kingsley, 2004) 7–10, 10.

Chappell

Points out that migration is both affected and affects development.1 Figure 1 “The Development-Migration-Development Nexus”2 Table outlines the development impact of migration on country of origin in different areas.3


1L Chappell & D Sriskandarajah, Mapping the Development Impacts of Immigration, Development on the Move: Working Paper 1, (London: IPPR, 2007) 4.
2L Chappell & D Sriskandarajah, Mapping the Development Impacts of Immigration, Development on the Move: Working Paper 1, (London: IPPR, 2007) 4.
3L Chappell & D Sriskandarajah, Mapping the Development Impacts of Immigration, Development on the Move: Working Paper 1, (London: IPPR, 2007) 9–12.

Black et al

Version:1.0 StartHTML:0000000168 EndHTML:0000007386 StartFragment:0000000805 EndFragment:0000007369
Complexity of reasons for coming to the UK but include 1) safety, 2) existence of family members 3) human rights record.4) Economic opportunities1
illegal entry usually carried out by an agent.2
occupation usually within unskilled jobs especially in restaurants.3 lack of paperwork places constrain on type of work which can be done, and exposes migrants to exploitation, low pay and long hours.4 false documents means of better employment and higher pay.5
tendency to avoid or defer going to a doctor due to illegal status, preference for a pharmacist instead.6
High incidence of detention after raids at home or at work, or random checks by police in the street.7
“There was a common theme amongst respondents of the surprise of the raid, and the lack of time they were given to gather personal belongings, money and phone numbers. Respondents talked of how they werequickly arrested, taken to a police station and then moved to a detention centre that was often very far away from where they had lived, and where their friends and contacts were. It was clear that those who had been in the country for shorter periods of time, without good social networks, often lost everything in terms of
housing and possessions.”8
1R Black, M Collyer, R Skeldon & C Waddington, A Survey of the Illegally Resident Population in Detention in the UK, Home Office Online Report 20/05 available online at www.homeoffice.gov.uk/rds/pdfs05/r224.pdf [Accessed October 17 2008] 16–19.
2R Black, M Collyer, R Skeldon & C Waddington, A Survey of the Illegally Resident Population in Detention in the UK, Home Office Online Report 20/05 available online at www.homeoffice.gov.uk/rds/pdfs05/r224.pdf [Accessed October 17 2008] 20–22.
3R Black, M Collyer, R Skeldon & C Waddington, A Survey of the Illegally Resident Population in Detention in the UK, Home Office Online Report 20/05 available online at www.homeoffice.gov.uk/rds/pdfs05/r224.pdf [Accessed October 17 2008] 26.
4R Black, M Collyer, R Skeldon & C Waddington, A Survey of the Illegally Resident Population in Detention in the UK, Home Office Online Report 20/05 available online at www.homeoffice.gov.uk/rds/pdfs05/r224.pdf [Accessed October 17 2008] 26–28.
5R Black, M Collyer, R Skeldon & C Waddington, A Survey of the Illegally Resident Population in Detention in the UK, Home Office Online Report 20/05 available online at www.homeoffice.gov.uk/rds/pdfs05/r224.pdf [Accessed October 17 2008] 29.
6R Black, M Collyer, R Skeldon & C Waddington, A Survey of the Illegally Resident Population in Detention in the UK, Home Office Online Report 20/05 available online at www.homeoffice.gov.uk/rds/pdfs05/r224.pdf [Accessed October 17 2008] 39.
7R Black, M Collyer, R Skeldon & C Waddington, A Survey of the Illegally Resident Population in Detention in the UK, Home Office Online Report 20/05 available online at www.homeoffice.gov.uk/rds/pdfs05/r224.pdf [Accessed October 17 2008] 41–42.
8R Black, M Collyer, R Skeldon & C Waddington, A Survey of the Illegally Resident Population in Detention in the UK, Home Office Online Report 20/05 available online at www.homeoffice.gov.uk/rds/pdfs05/r224.pdf [Accessed October 17 2008] 43.

Wednesday, 1 October 2008

Moxon

claims of widespread failure within the Home Office's Immigration and Nationality Directorate1 (1)

claims that “Britain is currently sustaining uncontrolled mass net immigration”2 (2)

“honesty about immigration looks like the thin end of a highly interesting wedge that could benefit us all.”3 (3)

affirms that the problem with migration is that those coming are unskilled and unsocialised in Western ways.4 (4-5)

“It is undeniable that these communities are necessarily divisive in their very presence within the cities where they are located.”5 (6)

note the use of a military analogy, in which immigration officers are presented as the “front line” protecting the country from attack.6 (7)


affirms that there is a lack of numbers and resources to support the work of immigration officers.7 (9)

denies that there is economic benefit from migration.8 (44-58) (1) no imminent decline in native population9 (45) (2) pension crises easily resolved by simple reforms such as ending compulsory retirement and raising retirement age.10 (45-47) (3) loss of jobs by native workers, and fall in wages11 (47) (4) cost in providing social services for migrants12 (48)

blames the importing of unskilled migrant workers for the industrial decline of Northern cities at a time when technological investment was required.13 (49)

claims that migration increases inequality in UK (a) employers benefit more than workers (b) inequality amongst migrants.14

counters Home Office claims that UK is 2-3 billion p/a better off with immigration claiming that it does not include many neglected costs.15

seems to suggest that migration is to blame for many men becoming unattractive to women because they cannot support themselves.16

points to abuse in the Work Permit system17

“problem of the free rider invading a host society from outside”18

claims the victim of migration is the “work ing class male”19

1S Moxon, The Great Immigration Scandal, (Exeter: Imprint Academic, 2004) 1.

2S Moxon, The Great Immigration Scandal, (Exeter: Imprint Academic, 2004) 2.

3S Moxon, The Great Immigration Scandal, (Exeter: Imprint Academic, 2004) 3.

4S Moxon, The Great Immigration Scandal, (Exeter: Imprint Academic, 2004) 4–5.

5S Moxon, The Great Immigration Scandal, (Exeter: Imprint Academic, 2004) 6.

6S Moxon, The Great Immigration Scandal, (Exeter: Imprint Academic, 2004) 7.

7S Moxon, The Great Immigration Scandal, (Exeter: Imprint Academic, 2004) 9.

8S Moxon, The Great Immigration Scandal, (Exeter: Imprint Academic, 2004) 44–58.

9S Moxon, The Great Immigration Scandal, (Exeter: Imprint Academic, 2004) 45.

10S Moxon, The Great Immigration Scandal, (Exeter: Imprint Academic, 2004) 45-47.

11S Moxon, The Great Immigration Scandal, (Exeter: Imprint Academic, 2004) 47.

12S Moxon, The Great Immigration Scandal, (Exeter: Imprint Academic, 2004) 48.

13S Moxon, The Great Immigration Scandal, (Exeter: Imprint Academic, 2004) 49.

14S Moxon, The Great Immigration Scandal, (Exeter: Imprint Academic, 2004) 50.

15S Moxon, The Great Immigration Scandal, (Exeter: Imprint Academic, 2004) 51.

16S Moxon, The Great Immigration Scandal, (Exeter: Imprint Academic, 2004) 53.

17S Moxon, The Great Immigration Scandal, (Exeter: Imprint Academic, 2004) 56–57.

18S Moxon, The Great Immigration Scandal, (Exeter: Imprint Academic, 2004) 73.

19S Moxon, The Great Immigration Scandal, (Exeter: Imprint Academic, 2004) 74.